Religion in the MCU Diegesis

In a fun but intriguing bit of a mental exercise, Fandom’s Lon Harris asks, if the events of Marvel Cinetmatic Universe films happened in real life, how might they affect faith and religion? It’s a question we at Sacred and Sequential have asked many times of the comics’ diegeses and storyworlds, so it’s a worthwhile scenario to consider for the film characters.

Harris speaks with Marvel Editor Tom Breevort “specifically, in a 2005 interview with the “:

Breevort explained that, in his mind, characters in the Marvel universe have a separate mental category for superheroes, independent from regular mortals or gods.

“For the average person in the Marvel universe,” Breevort explained, “they look at Thor and they say he is a superhero. He is no different than a Mr. Fantastic or Spider-Man or Cyclops; his get-up, his shtick, his whatever, is based on the mythological god of thunder. But I do not believe that most people in the Marvel universe actually believe he is the bona fide article.”

So denial — or, at least, lack of awareness — keep influence of religious institutions at bay. Eventually, though, “[e]very expert I spoke with — Christian or otherwise — felt that American evangelical Christianity would face the toughest challenges from the events of the Marvel Cinematic Universe.”

Next Up for Superheroes: Religion?

Photo by RedZero44 on DeviantArt
Outside the 2014 San Diego Comic-Con

South Asia’s Madras Courier offered a novel op-ed this January from multi-hyphenate Tejaswy Nandury, which argues that the next evolution of comic book superheroes is into religion.

This thought may seem absurd to short term thinkers. If you, like me, are a long term strategist, you will instantly grasp this notion. Marvel already has the mythology, and the mass following, required to scale it up as a global religious operation. It just needs to add some necessary elements to give the MCU a religious gravitas.

Nandury seems to be thinking of the global and multicultural reach of Marvel Entertainment’s films, but he does acknowledge that the leap from page to screen was already the first step in this trajectory. More specifically, he feels that this “source material” that prizes science and liberal philosophy, not to mention capitalism, in its main ethos. This “scientific religion” can base its home and rituals in San Diego’s Comic-Con International, “just as Christmas evolved out of a pagan Roman festival.”

As quirky as Nandury’s idea might be, the only part of it that is actually erroneous is his thinking on its soteriology: Marvel’s comics and films already has a mess of options concerning “salvation” (some of which were explored in this episode of the Vox Populorum podcast, incidentally). However outlandish Nandury’s proposal might be, it’s only this element of it that would need of revision, serious or otherwise.

Sacred and Sequential’s Top Overall 2019 Stories

Following our year-end listing of the top new stories in 2019, the question arose as to what were the top overall postings in 2019. That is, what were the most-read articles, regardless of what year they were published.

So, to satisfy curiosity, here are Sacred and Sequential‘s most-read pages over the course of 2019:

5.

Review – Toscano and Hartmann-Dow’s The Amazing Adventures of the Afterbirth of Jesus

4.

More Than You Ever Wanted to Know on Black Panther and Religion

3.

Kleefeld Questions Chuck Dixon on Racism, Islamophobia, Antisemitism, etc. of White Nationalist ALT-HERO

2.

The Cthulhu Cosmology in Hellboy

1.

The Tangled Relationship Between Religion and Comics

Sacred and Sequential’s Top 2019 Stories

As 2019 draws to a close, we at Sacred and Sequential wanted to take a look back at the year that was and recount the five most-viewed new posts. (Postings from previous years were not included in this list.)

Ultimately, it looks like comics Jesus and calls for new scholarship attracted the most attention! What’s coming in 2020?

Our thanks to all who contributed — and especially those who linked to us and read!

5.

Religion, Spirituality, and Comics – A Sampler (Part 1 of 3)

4.

Kingstone Asks: WILL THE REAL JESUS PLEASE STAND UP?

3.

No to Jesus with superheroes; Yes to Jesus with kung-fu beheadings

2.

CFP – Religion and Comics Series

1.

CFP – Marveling Religion: Critical Discourse and the Marvel Cinematic Universe

Religion, Spirituality, and Comics – A Sampler (Part 3 of 3)

In the final part of this threepart sampler of religion and spirituality in comics and graphic novels, we look first at The Magdalena, the most active example of the warrior nun genre in comics, dip into Matt Murdock’s Catholicism in Daredevil: Guardian Devil, and finish up with atheist J. Michael Straczynski’s spiritual road trip exploring faith, hope, theodicy, and sacrifice. After that, a brief list of other comics that might be of interest is provided.

8. The Magdalena

Warrior nuns. Not the first thing you think of when you think of comics. But they are a thing, and an explicit connection between religion and comics. The most well-known and developed are Warrior Nun Areala and The Magdalena, as well as others such as Chrono Crusade, The Sisterhood and, obliquely, Sisters of Sorrow. Of all of these, The Magdalena is currently the most active, with the Reformation story line, published in 2017,  setting up the series for further adventures with a further generations of the supernatural protector.

The Magdalena first appeared in 1998 in the comic series, The Darkness, set in Top Cow’s universe that includes Witchblade, the Angelus, the Aphrodite characters, and the Artifacts series. Over time, she appeared in various crossovers as well as her own eponymous title. The Magdalena character is cast as the supernatural and superheroic protector of the Catholic church and wider world. Armed with the Spear of Destiny, the Magdalena is the Church’s trouble shooter – a kind of special operations figure – handling things the regular church apparatus can’t handle. The Magdalena conforms to the warrior nun genre in a variety of ways: attractive, energetic women, serving in a Catholic-oriented religious order, with martial arts skills, often with a connection to Mary Magdalene, and who engage in both spiritual activities and physical violence in the pursuit of opposing evil in accordance with the Catholic Church’s will. Continue reading Religion, Spirituality, and Comics – A Sampler (Part 3 of 3)

@ the intersection of religion and comics: Graphic Religion